While the How I Met Your Mother series finale was by no means a Dexter-level disaster, fans were left scratching their heads at the perplexing decision to make perpetual bachelor bro Barney get married to Robin, only to divorce three years later so she and Ted could finally, inevitably get together.
Now, fans are more likely to see her in a fashion magazine or doing a random blog interview than they are to see her on the silver screen.
This time around, Hannigan was a bit more tempered in her public enthusiasm for the project.